How to make decisions in meetings
Many meetings end with everyone agreeing to “circle back”. Usually the problem isn’t the people. It’s that nobody knew who was supposed to decide, or what exactly was being decided. A few well-known frameworks fix that.
Name the roles before the meeting: DACI
Atlassian’s DACI decision-making play gives every decision four roles:
- Driver: owns the process, gathers information and keeps it moving;
- Approver: the one person who makes the final call;
- Contributors: people with knowledge or opinions worth hearing;
- Informed: people who are told the outcome afterwards, and don’t need to be in the room.
Having exactly one Approver is the key. It doesn’t mean ignoring others; it means someone is clearly responsible for ending the debate.
RAPID for bigger decisions
Bain & Company’s RAPID decision-making framework works the same way with five roles: Recommend, Agree, Perform, Input and Decide. It’s usually saved for high-stakes or cross-team decisions, where it’s easy for responsibility to get lost. One person can hold several roles.
Write it down first
Amazon is well known for replacing slide decks with written, narrative memos of up to six pages. Meetings start with everyone reading the memo in silence, then discussing it. Jeff Bezos describes the practice, and how long a good memo takes to write, in his 2017 letter to shareholders. Even without going that far, sending a one-page proposal ahead of time makes a decision meeting much shorter: people arrive having already thought about it.
Formal groups: Robert’s Rules
Boards, clubs, school committees and other formal groups often run meetings with Robert’s Rules of Order: a standard set of procedures for making motions, debating and voting. It’s more structure than a team sync needs, but it’s a fair, well-tested way for a larger group to reach a decision everyone can see was made properly.
Whatever framework you use
- State the decision as a question in the agenda (see writing a meeting agenda).
- Say up front who decides, and by when.
- Share the options and the facts before the meeting.
- End by saying the decision out loud, then write it down where people can find it.